MLB Lockout Could Cost Sportsbooks Nearly $2 Billion

MLB’s labor deal expires Dec. 1, and owners are expected to lock players out. Citizens analysts estimate a lost season could wipe out about $19 billion in baseball handle, with DraftKings and FanDuel facing Q2 2027 handle drops of 32% and 33%. Kalshi traders give roughly a one-in-four chance of no baseball until mid-July.

6 min read

Major League Baseball’s collective bargaining agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. ET on Dec. 1, and owners are widely expected to lock out the players the next day. For sportsbooks, which rely on baseball to fill the quieter summer months, the timing is bad.

In a note to clients, Citizens analysts Jordan Bender and Isabelle Slavin estimate that a full MLB season generates about $19 billion in sports betting handle. At a typical 10% hold, a canceled season would take nearly $2 billion in revenue away from US sportsbooks.

“While the duration of a potential lockout remains unknown, we believe it could meaningfully impact estimates and introduce uncertainty into companies’ outlooks when they provide guidance over the next two quarters,” they wrote.

Key Takeaways

  • Deadline: The MLB CBA expires at 11:59 p.m. ET on Dec. 1, and a lockout is widely expected.
  • The dispute: Owners want a hard salary cap of $258.2 million and a floor of $180.2 million from 2028. The players’ union has rejected it.
  • Handle at risk: About $19 billion a season, according to Citizens. At a 10% hold, that’s about $1.9 billion in sportsbook revenue.
  • Biggest losers: DraftKings (–32% handle in Q2 2027) and FanDuel (–33%) in a worst case, according to Citizens.
  • Kalshi’s odds: 29% chance of Opening Day before April 30, 52% before May 31, 75% before July 13.
  • Prediction markets too: $11.6 billion in dollar volume was traded on MLB contracts last year, 62% of it on Kalshi.

Why the Two Sides Are So Far Apart

This is the first time owners have proposed a salary cap since 1994, when the players went on strike on Aug. 12 and the World Series was canceled.

IssueOwnersPlayers (MLBPA)
Salary capHard cap of $258.2M from 2028Opposed
Salary floor$180.2M from 2028Opposed as part of a cap system
2027 seasonKeep the current system—
Free agent contractsMaximum of five yearsOpposed
Union argument—The cap would cut total player pay, partly because it leaves out about $400M in amateur signing bonuses

Commissioner Rob Manfred has taken a hard line. He told ESPN that owners “will not compromise” on a salary cap and said he “can’t imagine” them ratifying a deal without a cap and floor, adding that all 30 clubs back the demand. He has also said “there’s plenty of room for compromise” on other issues.

Bruce Meyer, the MLBPA’s interim executive director, rejected the cap proposal. MLB has stepped up its public campaign, releasing a five-minute “Level the Playing Field” video to make its case to fans.

MLB’s Recent Work Stoppages

YearStoppageLengthGames lost
1994–95Players’ strike232 daysRest of 1994 season and the World Series
2021–22Owners’ lockout99 daysNone in the regular season
2026–27Expected lockout from Dec. 2??

A lockout would be MLB’s 10th work stoppage since 1972. The 2021–22 lockout ended before any regular-season games were lost. It also came before most states had legal sports betting.

What Kalshi Traders Expect

Prediction markets are already pricing a long dispute.

Kalshi market: Opening Day before…Price (“Yes”)Implied chance
April 30, 202729¢29%
May 31, 202752¢52%
July 13, 2027 (end of All-Star break)75¢75%

Source: Kalshi via InGame.

That means traders see about a one-in-four chance of no MLB baseball until mid-July, and only a 29% chance the season starts by the end of April.

The Damage to Sportsbooks

Citizens says the two biggest US sportsbooks would take most of the hit.

“Applying 3Q26 handle market shares, we estimate FanDuel and DraftKings would face the largest EBITDA impacts if games are canceled, including handle declines of 32% for DraftKings in 2Q27 and 33% for FanDuel based on our current estimates,” Bender and Slavin wrote.

MetricEstimate
MLB handle per full season~$19B (Citizens)
Revenue at a 10% hold~$1.9B
DraftKings Q2 2027 handle in a worst case–32%
FanDuel Q2 2027 handle in a worst case–33%
MLB share of 2025 US handle ($166.94B, AGA)~11% (my calculation)

The impact varies a lot by state. In Missouri’s July 2026 report, MLB made up $135.2 million of $246.8 million in handle, about 55%. In Indiana the same month, baseball was 17.3% of handle.

Why Summer Matters Most

The bigger concern isn’t the lost baseball bets alone. It’s what happens to customers when there’s little else to bet on.

“Baseball helps sportsbooks maintain customer engagement during a seasonally weaker period of the sports calendar,” Citizens wrote. “The start of the MLB season coincides with the end of the NBA and NHL seasons, giving operators an opportunity to cross-sell customers into other sports if a lockout begins. That said, July and August are particularly important, as few other major leagues are active. A prolonged interruption could therefore weaken customer retention and activation ahead of the NFL, NBA, and NHL seasons in the fall.”

Sportsbooks usually use baseball in July and August to keep customers active before football starts. Without it, they’d have to spend more on marketing to win those customers back in September.

Prediction Markets Would Be Hit Too

Sportsbooks wouldn’t be the only ones affected. According to Aldrin Research, prediction markets traded $24.7 billion in notional volume on MLB last year, or $11.6 billion in dollar volume, which is closer to a handle figure. Kalshi accounted for 62% of MLB dollar volume across the prediction-market industry.

Polymarket, which became MLB’s exclusive prediction-market partner in April 2026, would lose its partner league’s games for as long as a lockout lasts.

PlatformMLB exposure
Sportsbooks (all)~$19B handle per season (Citizens)
Prediction markets (all)$11.6B dollar volume / $24.7B notional (2025)
Kalshi62% of prediction-market MLB dollar volume
PolymarketMLB’s exclusive prediction-market partner

Kalshi is in an unusual position: it’s pricing a risk that would also cut into its own volume.

What to Watch for After Dec. 1

The 2021–22 lockout lasted 99 days and ended in March, in time for a full season. That’s the best case for sportsbooks. The worst case is a repeat of 1994, when the dispute ran into August and canceled the World Series. Kalshi currently puts the chance of a delay past mid-July at about one in four.

Operators will give 2027 guidance in their Q4 earnings calls in February. If there’s still no deal by then, Citizens expects the lockout to weigh on those forecasts. DraftKings and FanDuel are already dealing with higher marketing costs, prediction-market competition and federal scrutiny of their advertising. Losing baseball for part of the summer would add another pressure.

FAQ: MLB Lockout and Sports Betting

When does the MLB labor deal expire?
The collective bargaining agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. ET on Dec. 1, 2026. Owners are widely expected to lock out players once it does.

How much would an MLB lockout cost sportsbooks?
Citizens estimates a full MLB season generates about $19 billion in handle. At a 10% hold, a canceled season would cost sportsbooks close to $2 billion in revenue.

Which sportsbooks would be hurt most?
DraftKings and FanDuel. Citizens estimates worst-case Q2 2027 handle declines of 32% for DraftKings and 33% for FanDuel.

Will the 2027 MLB season start on time?
Kalshi traders put the chance of Opening Day before April 30 at 29%, before May 31 at 52%, and before July 13 at 75%.

Trending

Editor’s Pick

100% Sign up Bonus up to $500 at Everygame

Let's Go →

Editor’s Picks

  1. ★★★★★ 4.9
    Get 2 x 100% up to $500 New customers only, 21+. WELCOME500: 100% match up to $500 on deposits of $50+ via card/bank. CRYPTO1K: 50% match up to $1,000 on crypto deposits. Both must be redeemed immediately after depositing.
  2. ★★★★★ 4.8
    50% match up to $200 on Xbet will match 50% of your First Credit Card Deposit in Bonus Bets. Minimum deposit $50. Match applies to first deposit only — choose crypto or card at signup. Bonus funds credited as free-play/bonus bets and must be wagered before withdrawal. Separate welcome offer available for casino play.
  3. ★★★★½ 4.7
    250% match up to $2,500 New customers only. Min deposit $25–$50 (verify). Use code WELCOME1 on first deposit. Bonus expires 7 days after activation. Slots/bingo/keno/scratch cards count 100% toward rollover; progressive slots do not contribute.
  4. ★★★★½ 4.5
    Deposit $10, Get $25 in Trade Credits New users only, 21+. Min deposit $10. Promo code required at sign-up. You get five $5 Trade Credits, each valid for 30 days. Credits can only be used on contracts priced $0.01–$0.60. Credits aren't withdrawable, but winnings from them are.

More news