On Oct. 2, Ohio told Novig it was “clearly engaged in bookmaking or facilitating bookmaking in violation of Ohio civil and criminal law” and gave it until Oct. 16 to stop offering sports event contracts in the state. Novig has now sued.
Ludlow Exchange LLC, which operates Novig, filed suit in the US District Court for the Northern District of Ohio against Attorney General Andy Wilson and Ohio Casino Control Commission officials. Reports put the filing on Nov. 16 or 17. Novig wants preliminary and permanent injunctions and a ruling that federal commodities law preempts Ohio’s gambling laws.
Most coverage will treat this as another preemption lawsuit. I’m more interested in where Novig chose to file. Ohio is in the Sixth Circuit, which ruled in September that Ohio and Tennessee can enforce their gambling laws against Kalshi. Novig is asking a court in that circuit to reach a different conclusion.
Key Takeaways
- The suit: Ludlow Exchange LLC (Novig) v. Ohio AG Andy Wilson and Ohio Casino Control Commission officials, N.D. Ohio.
- The trigger: Ohio’s Oct. 2 cease-and-desist letter, one of 10 sent to prediction-market platforms, with an Oct. 16 deadline.
- Seventh state: It’s Novig’s seventh state lawsuit since its near-nationwide launch in August.
- Novig’s argument: The CFTC’s October rulemaking weakens the Sixth Circuit’s KalshiEX v. Schuler ruling, which Novig calls “not final.”
- Other claims: Federal preemption under the Commodity Exchange Act, and that Ohio’s licensing rules discriminate against interstate commerce.
- Recent loss: A federal judge in New York denied Novig’s preliminary injunction on Nov. 10, ruling that sports contracts aren’t swaps.
What Ohio Told Novig
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Sept. 25 | Sixth Circuit rules 3-0 for Ohio and Tennessee in KalshiEX v. Schuler |
| Oct. 2 | Ohio sends cease-and-desist letters to 10 prediction-market platforms, including Novig |
| Oct. 16 | Ohio’s deadline to stop offering sports contracts |
| Oct. (date unclear) | CFTC rulemaking on event contracts |
| Nov. 6 | CFTC tells exchanges to stop geoblocking states within 30 days |
| Nov. 10 | SDNY denies Novig’s preliminary injunction in New York |
| Nov. 16–17 | Novig sues Ohio in N.D. Ohio |
Ohio’s letter said Novig is “operating online sports gaming” and relied directly on the Sixth Circuit’s Kalshi ruling.
Novig’s Argument: The CFTC Has Changed the Rules
Novig’s case depends on timing. It argues the CFTC’s October rulemaking undercuts the basis of the Sixth Circuit’s decision, and it calls that ruling “not final.” In other words, the appeals court ruled before the federal regulator clarified its position, so the lower court shouldn’t treat the ruling as settled.
Novig makes two further arguments:
- Preemption: The Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over swaps and event contracts traded on registered exchanges. Novig says it became a CFTC-designated contract market in June 2026.
- Interstate commerce: Ohio’s licensing scheme discriminates against out-of-state operators.
The complaint is marked as related to Underdog’s pending suit against Ohio. Polymarket US and Robinhood have also sued the state, so a single Ohio federal court is now dealing with several prediction-market challenges.
Why File in the Circuit Where Kalshi Lost?
A district court in Ohio is bound by Sixth Circuit precedent. Novig is unlikely to get an injunction that contradicts KalshiEX v. Schuler outright. So why sue?
Three reasons stand out to me:
- To build the CFTC argument for appeal. If the Supreme Court takes up preemption (Kalshi’s response to New Jersey’s petition is due Dec. 7), operators want a record showing the CFTC’s newer rules change the analysis.
- To answer the CFTC’s 30-day directive. The Nov. 6 interpretation tells exchanges to stop geoblocking or explain why they can’t. Active litigation against the state is a strong explanation, whichever way Novig ends up deciding.
- To protect itself from enforcement. Ohio’s letter accuses Novig of “bookmaking.” A pending federal case gives Novig a defence if Ohio escalates.
Novig’s Seven State Lawsuits
| State | Status |
|---|---|
| Ohio | Filed Nov. 16–17 in N.D. Ohio |
| New York | Preliminary injunction denied Nov. 10 (court ruled sports contracts aren’t swaps). Novig appealing |
| Missouri | Sued in E.D. Missouri in October, alongside Crypto.com |
| Four others | Filed since Novig’s August launch (not all named in coverage) |
New York’s ruling hurts Novig’s case. Judge after judge has ruled against operators, and only the Third Circuit has sided with Kalshi.
Who Novig Is
Novig is smaller than Kalshi but growing fast:
| Metric | Figure |
|---|---|
| Model | Sports-only peer-to-peer exchange |
| Seven-day volume (to Nov. 15) | $850.5M (Kalshi: $27.5B) |
| Fundraising | Reportedly at a $2B valuation (Sept.) |
| Marketing | Sydney Sweeney campaign and equity stake |
| Regulatory issues | Told by the CFTC in October to pause “scorigami” and micro contracts |
It also dropped American odds formatting in what looked like a response to the CFTC’s directive, a sign of how closely sports-only exchanges have to manage how much they look like sportsbooks.
Why Ohio Matters
Ohio has a legal, taxed sportsbook market, and lawmakers are considering online casinos for 2027. The state’s position is simple: if you take sports bets in Ohio, you need an Ohio licence. Kalshi tested that argument in the Sixth Circuit and lost.
Novig is betting that the CFTC’s rulemaking changes the outcome, and Polymarket, Robinhood and Underdog are betting the same way in the same court. If a district judge agrees, it would be the first crack in the Sixth Circuit’s ruling. If not, the operators will have built their record for the Supreme Court, where the decision will ultimately be made.
FAQ: Novig vs. Ohio
Why is Novig suing Ohio?
Ohio sent Novig a cease-and-desist letter on Oct. 2, saying its sports event contracts amount to illegal bookmaking. Novig argues federal commodities law preempts Ohio’s gambling laws and wants a federal court to block enforcement.
What is Novig?
Novig is a sports-focused prediction-market exchange operated by Ludlow Exchange LLC. It says it’s a CFTC-designated contract market and has operated near-nationwide since August 2026.
Didn’t Kalshi already lose in Ohio?
Yes. The Sixth Circuit ruled 3-0 on Sept. 25, 2026, that Ohio and Tennessee can enforce their gambling laws against Kalshi. Novig argues the CFTC’s October rulemaking undercuts that ruling.
How many states has Novig sued?
Ohio is Novig’s seventh state lawsuit since its August launch. It recently lost a preliminary injunction bid in New York.








